If you are a business with revenue that wants several directions to choose from, take 99designs. If you are somebody who needs a workable logo for a fraction of the price, take Fiverr. Here is the reasoning.
Part of a bigger question. This is one example of a broader topic — How Do I Get Clients For A Small Business?. Start there if you want the full picture.
99designs vs Fiverr: the short answer for a t-shirt design
If you are a business with revenue that wants several directions to choose from, take 99designs. If you are somebody who needs a workable logo for a fraction of the price, take Fiverr. That is the whole answer and everything below is the reasoning.
99designs gives you multiple concepts and costs several hundred dollars. Fiverr gives you one designer and costs a fraction. In month one, Fiverr is the right answer.
Here is the part most comparison articles will not tell you. Buy design out of profit, not out of savings. If you have not found your first customer, neither of these is your priority.
I earn a commission on one of these and not the other, and I have just told you when the other one wins. That is the only way any of this is worth reading.
What each one costs
99designs. Contest packages from a few hundred dollars.
Fiverr. Per gig, often under $100 for a logo.
Run both against your own volume before deciding. A percentage that looks small becomes a real number across a year, and most t-shirt design owners have never worked out what they actually pay.
The headline price is rarely the real cost. What matters is the total across a year at your volume, including whatever the add-ons cost once you actually need them.
Recommended Tool
Free tool
What Should You Charge Per Hour?
Put in your costs and your real hours. Get the number you should actually be charging.
Where 99designs genuinely wins
For a t-shirt design, 99designs wins on the things that matter when you are starting or staying small.
It is cheaper to begin with and the commitment is lower. That matters when 64% of people say money is what is stopping them, and it means a wrong decision costs you less.
The setup is simpler and you do not need anybody technical. For a t-shirt design with no support staff, that is not a minor point.
And it is genuinely adequate. The most common mistake is buying the more capable tool before you have the problem it solves.
Where Fiverr genuinely wins
This is the section most affiliate comparisons skip, which is exactly why they are not worth reading.
Fiverr is the better choice for somebody who needs a workable logo for a fraction of the price. That is not a hedge. It is the honest answer, and if it describes you then you should take it.
Buy design out of profit, not out of savings. If you have not found your first customer, neither of these is your priority.
Buying the wrong tool because a review told you to is expensive, and it is expensive in a way that is hard to undo once your data lives inside it.
How to actually decide
Answer three questions honestly and the choice makes itself.
What is your actual volume? Not what you hope it will be. What it is this month. Most tool decisions are made on aspiration and paid for in reality.
What is the problem currently costing you the most? If it is not the problem this tool solves, then neither option is your priority and the money belongs somewhere else.
And how hard is it to leave? Check the exit before you enter. That question is boring right up until it is the only question that matters.
What I would do first, before either
Almost every t-shirt design I talk to could improve their numbers this month without spending a dollar.
Work out what one job actually earns per hour, including the time nobody bills for. That figure is almost always lower than the one in your head, and it changes what you accept.
Complete your business profile properly. Free, dull, and the highest-return hour available to a t-shirt design.
Follow up on every quote from the last two months that went quiet. A meaningful share are recoverable.
Do those three, then choose a tool. A tool applied to a business with no systems just makes the chaos faster.
The verdict for a t-shirt design
99designs gives you multiple concepts and costs several hundred dollars. Fiverr gives you one designer and costs a fraction. In month one, Fiverr is the right answer.
If you are a business with revenue that wants several directions to choose from, 99designs is the right call and I would not spend another week deciding.
If you are somebody who needs a workable logo for a fraction of the price, take Fiverr and do not feel bad that it is not the one with my link on it.
The worst outcome is buying either one because a comparison article told you to, without running the numbers against your own business first.
What holds people back
The obstacle is rarely knowledge. Most t-shirt design owners broadly know what they should be doing, and the gap between knowing and doing is where the difficulty sits.
Part of it is that comparing tools feels like progress and requires none of the uncomfortable work. That is exactly why the tabs stay open for weeks and nothing changes.
Thirty-three percent of my audience told me they research all day and never start. Research feels like progress and carries no risk of being wrong in public.
Pick one. Get it working. You can change it later, and the cost of a wrong choice is far smaller than the cost of another month deciding.
The numbers to know before you spend anything
Very few t-shirt design owners can answer these quickly, and each one is worth an afternoon.
What does one job actually earn you per hour, once you count preparation, travel, cleanup, and the follow-up nobody bills for? That figure is almost always lower than the one in your head, and it changes what you accept.
How much work is booked for next month, how many invoices are unpaid, and how old is the oldest one? Those three questions answered every Friday will show you a squeeze six weeks before your bank balance does.
Which job type quietly carries the business, and which one feels profitable and is not? There is nearly always one of each, and most owners have them backwards.
None of this requires software. It requires an hour and a willingness to see the answer, and the numbers are already true whether or not you look at them.
Four weeks that would change the picture
Week one, work out what a job actually earns per hour, all in.
Week two, separate the business money completely. Business account, business only. That is what turns a thing that makes money into an asset you could sell or borrow against.
Week three, complete your business profile properly and ask three happy customers for a review that mentions the specific job. Specific reviews are what get you found for specific searches.
Week four, follow up on every quote from the last two months that went quiet. A meaningful share are recoverable and nobody else is going to chase them for you.
That is a month, it costs nothing, and it moves a t-shirt design further than any tool purchase would.
The timeline nobody tells you
I would rather set the expectation properly than have you quit in week five believing something is wrong with you.
The first stretch is quiet. Very few people know you exist and building that takes longer than any plan admits. This is normal and it is not evidence the idea was wrong.
The first real money frequently arrives between month two and month four, and it is smaller than you hoped. It matters enormously anyway, because it proves the loop closes.
After that it compounds, slowly and then less slowly. The people it works for are not the talented ones. They are the ones still going when the fast starters have already moved on.
Fifty-two percent of my audience chose the phrase I am meant for more. If that is you, what stands between you and it is almost never information. It is a decision, followed by an unglamorous week.
Recommended
99designs
If the case above describes you, this is the one I would point you to.
Affiliate link — commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend what I would use.
The questions that come up most
Which one should I pick?
It depends on your volume and what problem is currently costing you the most. The page above says plainly which situation each one fits.
Do you earn from these links?
Yes, on some of them. Which is exactly why I have said where the option I do not earn from is the better choice.
What should I do before buying anything?
Work out what a job actually earns per hour, complete your business profile, and follow up on quotes that went quiet. All free, all higher return than any tool.
Can I switch later?
Usually, and it costs more than you expect. Check how hard it is to export your data before you commit, not after.
Business Resources You Can Use
- Website Hosting Get online for $3.99/moBluehost
- Create a New LLC Register your business rightMyCorp
- Logo & Brand Design Stand out from day one99designs
- Email Marketing Best for beginnersConstant Contact
- Payments & Invoicing In-person and onlineSquare
- SEO & Market Research Find your customersSEMrush
- AI Presentations & Docs Make marketing materials fastGamma
- Hire Freelance Pros Outsource what you can't doFiverr Pro
- Email & Automation Turn buyers into repeat buyersKit
Free Download
Not sure where to start?
Grab The $0 Startup Checklist. It's every step you can take this week to start a business without spending money. In order. No fluff.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article uses affiliate links and may earn a commission from certain links, at no extra cost to you. Opinions expressed are our own.